Thats not a knock against book of life, i enjoyed the movie. Coco is a 2017 american 3d computeranimated musical fantasy film produced by pixar animation studios and released by walt disney pictures. His character arc is well done, and though manolo is the lead in the book of life, the best character development in that film belongs to joaquin. I did not think i would love this movie so much, but im obsessed with it.
Coco was announced in 2012, right before the book of life started production, and the latter had been in the works in some form or another since as early as 2001. There you have it, some of the similarities between coco and the book of life. Should we be upset at the similarity between the films or is there a reason to celebrate them both. In responding to these types of prompts, you often will compare and contrast characters, concepts, or choices. Despite similarities to foxs 2014 the book of life, coco also takes a positive cultural step for mainstream american entertainment, with its alllatino voice cast. The music, the colors, the animation style, loved all of it. The teaser trailer looked interesting and beautiful, but some fans of another day of the dead animation are a little pissed off. Get an answer for what are some of the main differences between the life of pi film and book. And yet theres the thrill of finishing with a book.
Coco and the book of life are good films, and i would recommend checking both out. Were you able to spot the similarities while watching. Still, the two are very different in many dimensions. Stop comparing coco and the book of life her campus. Ultimately, coco is a fantastic movie worthy of the pixardisney brand which every family should enjoy. Pixar dropped the trailer for their next film coco.
I might be sounding a little negative and hard on the film so let me say something i really liked about it. Coco seems to draw more inspiration from pixars own ratatouille and hayao miyazakis spirited away than the book of life. Similarities between coco and the book of life joys of asia. Do you think coco seems too similar to the book of life. Does the events of coco take place in the same universe as.
Animation fans raged when disney and pixar staffers described coco as a unique idea about love and loss, done up in the colorful style of mexican folk art all of which describes the book of life, too. Make sure to leave your thoughts in the comments section down below i. The book of life vs coco thing does not exist in our dojo. In 2014, stop motion film the book of life was released and my only regret is not seeing it on the big screen. Disneypixars coco and reel fxs the book of life both take place on. Im almost always listening to the soundtrack, i have an allover print tank top of manolo and maria, and i have a manolo pop on my counter.
Pixars coco is a musical about the day of the dead and it will be the first from the studio with the lead being a person of color. I will start by summarizing the story of each movie, then i will list the similarities and the differences, then i will compare specifically their representation of the day of the dead and their use of music. Calling coco a ripoff of book of life is like calling hocus pocus a ripoff of halloweentown, or calling the santa clause a ripoff of a christmas story. Coco, the latest pixar movie, has been accused by some fans as being a. This is a comparison to see the similarities between coco and the book of life. The book of life is another animated film with similar. Is the new pixar movie a ripoff of the book of life. The book of life comparisons are a little too close for comfort, they say. The book of life is a love story that explores the importance of bravery and confronting ones own fears, while coco is a coming of age tale thats much more rooted in family. The guitar or passion of music this is here in both movie.
The book of life is a love story, while coco is a story about family. Since then, however, i have seen coco and while there are some similarities, they are very different movies. Coco vs the book of life a blog about animated films. Are coco and the book of life basically the same film. Cocos miguel, voiced by 12yearold newcomer anthony gonzalez, is a misfit who, like braves merida and a bugs lifes flik, has dreams too. Coco and the book of life both have a big focus on family, particularly on dead ancestors. There are some clear similarities in both films, as. Controversy struck again when fans of the film the book of life reacted to similarities between coco and the 2014 brainchild of mexican and mexicanamerican writers and artists, accusing disney of. I got to see coco over the weekend and i really enjoyed it but it couldnt help but remind me of the book of life. Is pixars coco really a ripoff of book of the life. Coco vs the book of life an animated film comparison by. The next similarity sees both protagonists manolo and miguel being. Long noted for its similarities to the 2014 jorge gutierrez film, the book of life, the trailer for coco hasnt assuaged fears that its a ripoff. The book of life is about a love triangle between a strong soldier.
The book of life developing emotional intelligence the book of life is the brain of the school of life, a gathering of the best ideas around wisdom and emotional intelligence. And just today i saw the trailer for coco and immediately thought of the book of life. I heard a lot of people praise book of life when coco was coming out, and i can see why now, because there are a number of thematic and story similarities between the two. Coco and the book of life are two movies related to the day of the dead oct. Both movies feature male protagonists who play the guitar and sing. However, many people see coco as a copy of, or cant help but compare it to the 2014 film the book of life because of several similarities. Since these two movies have so much in common, i thought it would be fun to compare them.
Given the beloved status of the cat concerto and rhapsody rabbit after 70 years, its almost assured that the existence of both films will be to their mutual benefit. Pixars acclaimed adventure coco from 2017 would later run into controversy for its plot similarities to the book of life, though jorge gutierrez would profess his excitement for the lee unkrich directed movie. Pixars coco called ripoff by angry fans of similar day of the dead. Coco vs the book of life whats better 2018 hd youtube. The book of life 2 2020 yify download movie torrent hd. The book of life directors outspoken support stood in stark contrast to the response of his films defenders. Prior to release, my two concerns with the movie was that it would be a heartless pixar version of the book of life, and that disney would take advantage and exploit the hispanic culture in a distasteful way. However, while there are superficial similarities in the same way that two movies set at christmas would be expected to share certain images, the plots are divergent. Where do you stand on the debate between coco and the book of life, and do you have to pick side when two similar movies come out. Because of their similar aesthetic styles and musical themes, the two movies have been compared relentlessly.
You will be asked to identify similarities and differences, which are the key to compareandcontrast essays. While the book of life is a wonderful, feelgood movie about love, family, and tradition that takes place during the day of the dead, coco is a film truly about the holiday that accurately captures the emotions and essence of a tradition that has strived for centuries to keep people connected to their. Both coco and the book of life are not just about the day of the dead, but also feature a live person travelling to the land of the dead. Each film creates a land where dead loved ones roam and themes of music are prevalent, but the similarities stop there. Both families have a pair of deceased twins who are side characters. They both also feature a lead character whose life revolves around their music. What is the difference between coco and the book of life. However, there are a lot of differences between the two as.
Lets look at what the book of life and coco actually have in common. Should we be upset of cocos similarity to the book of life. The movie is a day of the dead themed musical as well, using. It can easily accommodate two films with a similar basis, and given the three year difference between the book of life and coco, thats even more likely.
Coco is a stunning depiction of love, lineage, and. This setting actually made the film really enjoyable to watch because there were so many colorful eye candies. Coco, the latest pixar movie, has been accused by some fans as being a ripoff of the book of life, but is it. So in case you havent seen these films and want some context. On a standardized test, you may be asked to analyze literature, evaluate ideas, or make a judgment and explain your reasons. Coco is pixars latest film, and its first teaser shows a lot to be excited for. Coco, since its release, has seen widespread success across the u.
Both movies revolve around the theme of venerating the dead and music. Theres quite a few people who say that pixar ripped off sony when they made coco a few years after the book of life. Coco, in comparison, went above and beyond with vr, introducing the movies signature song remember me on dancing with the stars, and. Pixars coco called ripoff by angry fans of similar day. To put it bluntly in my opinion coco is simply a better film than book of life period. It gave me a bit of a funny feeling that a movie i loved so much seemed to be somewhat copied only a. Coco vs the book of life an animated film comparison by david. As obvious and familiar as this thematic territory can be, coco deals with it tenderly and sweetly, in ways that will send audiences young and old out with a song in their. Coco looks like its a boy and his dog heros journey, whereas the book of life was love triangle questdriven fare.
While some critics preemptively reduced coco to a book of life knockoff before it was released, comparing the two is a stretch. Miguel in coco is very much a regular kid, thinking in the short term and feeling frustrated with his familys rules. Manolo, maria and joaquin are three childhood best friends. Top 10 differencessimilarities between the book of life. Booklife resources and tools for book publishers and writers. If youve seen coco and the book of life, youve surely noticed some of the similarities. What are some of the main differences between the life of. Top 10 differencessimilarities between the book of life and coco. Book of life fans are calling out pixars coco for being a.
741 1186 1452 878 1413 263 923 302 357 1270 508 1371 1436 449 898 24 1598 984 287 233 1428 510 1110 1455 204 70 1224 1596 847 965 651 138 1137 650 533 321 1068 336 1106 1438 1326 738 1497